Skip to main content
Locksmith

Rekey or Replace Your Locks?

Rekeying and replacing both stop old keys working. Which one fits depends on the hardware you already have.

5 min read · Updated

Written and reviewed by Mark Battaglini, owner-operator of Rapid Response Handyman. Updated .

What Each Option Does

Rekeying changes the pins inside the existing cylinder so a new key works and old keys don't. The lock body, handle and finish stay. Replacing swaps the whole lockset or deadbolt.

Both solve the 'who still has a key' problem. The difference is whether the existing hardware is worth keeping.

Rekeying Makes Sense When

The hardware works smoothly, you like how it looks, and it's a lock that can be rekeyed.

  • You just moved in or changed tenants
  • A key was lost but the locks are in good shape
  • You want several compatible locks on one key

Replacement Makes Sense When

The hardware itself is the problem, or you want something it can't do.

  • The lock is worn, corroded or loose in the door
  • You want a sturdier deadbolt or a smart lock
  • Locks are mixed brands that can't be keyed alike
  • The style or finish needs to change

A Practical Middle Ground

Many homes end up with a mix: rekey the good locks, replace the one that's failing, and key them all alike. A locksmith can usually tell within a few minutes which locks are worth keeping.

Next useful thing to know

Local scope: Atlantic County and Cape May County. Find your town or neighborhood.

Bring the guide back to your property maintenance plan or compare repair and upgrade options.

Get this handled

Services in Atlantic & Cape May Counties related to this guide.

Service coverage includes Atlantic City, Egg Harbor Township, Mays Landing, Somers Point and across our South Jersey service areas.

Tell us what you need

Call, text, or send a few photos and a short description. Rapid Response serves Atlantic County and Cape May County, New Jersey.